Friday, January 16, 2015

privilege

 Take a minute, and without thinking about it too much, quickly list all the different ways in which you're privileged. Better yet, do it out loud. 

Now, did you find this relatively easy, or were you a bit stumped after the first couple of more obvious privileges? If you're like most of us, you were a bit slower in rattling off the last items you came up with, and that's not surprising given the nature of privilege. Privilege tends to be relatively invisible to the privilege-holder, that is, we often don't even see the advantages that come with the particular type of privilege we enjoy. And we all enjoy numerous privileges we take for granted.

If you are currently reading this post, then you enjoy heaps of privilege right off the bat. You have time, and are likely not working in multiple part-time jobs (or sweatshops) in trying to make ends meet. You have some kind of device on which you're reading these very words, and are probably living somewhere without Internet censorship. Almost certainly, you have some level of post-secondary education, or are self-taught. Already, as you can see, you are hugely privileged.

Statistically, many of you are enjoying gender privilege (it's easier, by the way, for vegans to pay lip service to the idea of being nonsexist than it is to recognize how certain approaches that value linear or black and white thinking, or reason over emotion, may actually be rooted in sexism), racial privilege, and heterosexual privilege. What may not be as easy to see is that you likely also enjoy gender identity privilege, Judeo-Christian privilege, and able-bodied privilege. If you fit the norms of whatever is considered attractive and desirable in your culture or society, than that's privilege too.

So right away, we have all sorts of privilege that we may not even be that aware of: gender, gender identity, class, racial, economic, technological, religious, education, orientation, and so forth -- it's a bit staggering, isn't it? Which isn't to say that anyone is completely privileged, as we're all probably marginalized in one area or another, and as with anything, it's a matter of degree.

But the one enormous privilege that the vast majority of us (even those of us who can easily recognize all sorts of other privileges) don't see, is the privilege conferred on human animals. In fact, this privilege is rendered so invisible that those of us who do see the anthropocentrism for what it is are usually accused of anthropomorphism. In other words, our world is so human-centric that many cannot recognize other sentient beings as beings in their own right, and dismiss veganism as an attempt to attribute human emotions and characteristics as if those emotions and traits can only be human. It's as if most humans cannot view members of other species but through a human-specific and human-oriented lens. Quite the disability, if you ask me. ;)

My friend veganelder has also been pondering this most peculiar inability, so I would invite you to read here, here, and here.

Please do think a bit more about the notion of privilege, the extent of your own particular set of privileges, how you can help those with fewer privileges, and how you can help other humans actually see the privilege-tinted lenses they wear. Thanks.

Oh, because privilege can be hard to think about objectively when you're the one enjoying its benefits, here are a few nifty lists of examples to make it a bit clearer:

So all we need now is for someone to write a 30+ examples of human privilege list. Sadly, it shouldn't be too difficult. 

Comments

Krissa said...

I thought about VE right before you mentioned him in this post. :) ... This is something I have thought about I have no idea how many times, especially lately. I usually don't think of it in relation to things like gender privilege or the others you mentioned (and I'll check out the links!)...it's in my mind so often how much power our unworthy species has over all others. It is too much for my mind to actually comprehend if I really concentrate on it. It is the ultimate privilege to be born human on this planet and I have no idea how 'we' managed to pull this off. Instead of rambling off all the examples I see every day, I'll just say that I remember when I was a kid being told that "privileges are something you earn". Ha. Of course in the context of being allowed to do something you want to do because you did something you didn't want to (chores, etc.) they can make that fly. But our species has absolutely NOT earned the privilege that we have over everyone else. And here I go but, once again we have organized religion to in great part thank for this.

Glad to see you were able to post again! Some worthwhile things to consider here!

have gone vegan said in reply to Krissa...

Thanks Krissa. I'm trying to keep the goals I actually didn't set (the idea being that if I DON'T set them I may have better luck), with one of them being to make/take the time to write even when I feel I don't have it. The funny thing though is that every time I DO post, I have at least one person unsubscribe within the hour, so I guess that means I'm doing something wrong, or actually something very right, snort.

I'm afraid though that it may have come across in this post that I'm completely enlightened when it comes to privilege, and that I recognize my various sorts of privilege and their consequences at all times, which is patently not the case. I'm as privilege-blind as everyone else more times than I'm comfortable with, but I think it's a concept that's useful and important, especially for vegans or anyone working to end oppression of any kind. Because if you don't see how seemingly different types of oppression are similar and interconnected (that is, the roots are the same but the affected party may be different), then you won't be as effective in whatever advocacy work you're doing.

And I agree that the human species has not earned its privilege, although it certainly is enjoying/abusing it to the detriment of others.

Krissa said in reply to have gone vegan...

That's wacky about the un-subs! It must be folks who don't even check the post out and just unsubscribe because they feel like they're getting too many emails. ? I unsubscribed to a few things lately because I was just getting way too many petitions and a good number of them nothing I would have been interested in. I just can't imagine anyone unsubbing after reading your posts!

Yep, our species hasn't earned any of the rights and privileges we enjoy and abuse. It's just nice and sanity-saving to know that there are some examples of humanity that are doing what they can to make things better for everyone else.

have gone vegan said in reply to Krissa...

Ha ha, you're probably right, and it likely has nothing even to do with me. Taking things personally has never been one of my finer qualities, snort.

And yes, those examples are what I cling to, and try to remember or view daily. :)

veganelder said...

I'm heartened to see that this privilege notion is of interest to you. That list of links you offer is a great resource to provoke some (maybe disturbing) thinking. Thank you.

I'm really struggling with all this stuff...I find it to be disturbing and powerful and disorienting...all at the same time and that's often really uncomfortable. Jeez, no wonder we tend to stay away from looking at notions of privilege and oppression except in some more superficial ways.

It's tough...thanks for writing about this.

have gone vegan said in reply to veganelder...

It's tough indeed. Veganism isn't just about giving up consuming other animals, it's about giving up power over others, all others. It's turned out to be a tad more complicated than I thought when I went vegan nearly seven years ago, snort.

Hi Friend,
Powerful post about the power of privilege and the privilege of power. I believe that giving up the notion that we deserve to have power over others can lead us in the direction of understanding and appreciating the biggest privilege of all-and that is life. If we give life the reverence it deserves then all living beings fall under its protection. No need for violence, no need to enslave, no need to convince others that being vegan is good for them in terms of health and so on.
many thanks,
Anne

Well put Anne!

With privilege comes responsibility, but unfortunately, in its place is usually self-entitlement. And when that self-entitlement is species-wide, well, the end result ain't pretty.

No comments:

Post a Comment